Design Review II

Home Schedule Policies Resources Design Notebooks

Purpose

In this design review, your initial hardware design will be reviewed. Your schematic design will be critiqued for completeness and proper design. Your part selection will be critiqued for appropriate selection and identification of alternative parts.

Preparation

Your team should have turned in the following documents by 11:00 AM on the day of the review:

  1. Parts list/cost estimate

  2. Schematic (if applicable)

  3. Draft Mechanical Systems (if applicable)

  4. Draft UI and Technical Interface documents

  5. Updated schedule - email to instructor

All team members must be present at all design reviews. Students with unexcused absences from design reviews will receive a zero grade for the design review.

Each member should be generally familiar with all parts selected and all portions of the schematic. Each member should be intimately familiar with at least one subsection of the design (i.e. power supply or A/D front end). The reviewers will ask each team member detailed questions about the area(s) of their responsibility.

Grading

Grading will reflect how well the team has prepared the initial hardware design.

Category Percentage of score
Part Selection/Cost estimate - All parts are identified, along with required information on suppliers, prices, and alternatives. 20
Schematic/Mechanical Design - Complete and well-drawn. Technical design in each area is sound. 40
Draft UI document - Adequately describes the User Interface including illustrations 20
Draft Technical Interface document - Adequately describes all electrical/mechanical interfaces 10
Schedule - Schedule is up-to-date, with progress marked. Team is on schedule. 10

Kevin Bolding January 10, 2012